ASH Australia media release
                                        May 12, 2005

ACCC ends misleading conduct over light/mild cigarettes but $8m not enough to remedy harm

 

Back to Media Releases index

Health groups have welcomed a ban on the misleading and deceptive descriptors “light” and “mild” on tobacco products but say the two multi-national tobacco companies have been let off the hook with a one-off total payment of $8m to remedy massive harm to consumers.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) announced late today that it had resolved its lengthy investigation into misleading tobacco branding (“light”, “mild” and all similar terms), with a court enforceable undertaking from two of the three major tobacco companies operating in Australia.

The misleading descriptors will be removed by mid 2005 but the companies, BAT and Philip Morris, will only have to pay $4m each to fund consumer education programs to remedy the harm caused by their unlawful conduct.

“Mass media campaigns are expensive and experts estimate that $8m for education programs will only go part of the way towards funding the remedies that are necessary to reverse the harm caused by this consumer fraud”, says Anne Jones of ASH Australia.

Meanwhile, light and mild cigarettes have made the tobacco industry millions of dollars as most smokers rather than quitting, switched to lights because they wrongly believed them to be less harmful.

Health experts estimate that a sustained campaign to counter the harm from the lights scam, reducing the proportion of users believing they are less harmful from 55% to 5%, would cost over twenty times the amount accepted by the ACCC.

The third tobacco company – Imperial Tobacco Australia – is refusing to agree to ACCC demands for banning the misleading terms or paying for corrective advertising.

Health groups are seeking more information, including how the ACCC derived such an inadequate estimate of $8m to counter the consumer fraud.

ACCC media release is at  www.accc.gov.au/content/index.phtml/itemId/607418/fromItemId/142

Comment:  Anne Jones, CEO, ASH Australia   ph. (02) 9334-1876   m. 0417-227-879

Media inquiries:   Stafford Sanders   ph. (02) 9334-1823    m. 0412-070-194  

 

Page last updated 13/5/05