ASH Australia media release
                                       Date

Tobacco company misleads Councils 
to derail smokefree dining

 

Back to Media Releases index

 

The tobacco industry is once more trying to hoodwink local councils into dumping popular moves to make crowded outdoor eating and working areas smokefree.

Wagga Wagga City Council (NSW) has new policies on exhibition* until November 28, including proposals to ban smoking near children’s playgrounds and council building entrances, in covered bus shelters and taxi ranks, and in al fresco dining areas under council licence.

British American Tobacco Australasia (BATA) has written to Wagga Wagga City councillors (November 2008)** opposing the popular smokefree al fresco reform.

In the letter, BATA makes several unsubstantiated claims:

  • Smokefree al fresco rules are “potentially crippling”  for small business and “very difficult” to enforce;
  • “Some… anti-smoking advocates are against anti-smoking bans”, selectively quoting world tobacco control expert Professor Simon Chapman;  and
  • Education/butt-bin strategies of the Butt Littering Trust (BLT), funded by BATA, have led to “an average reduction in butt litter of 24.9%”.

Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) Australia has made a submission to the Wagga review supporting the proposed measures, backed by a wide range of health, medical, employee, child protection, church and local government organisations.

Says ASH CEO Anne Jones:  “These reforms are strongly supported by evidence and public opinion.

“All of Queensland, and more than fifty NSW councils, have adopted smokefree outdoor areas policies, including seven NSW councils with smokefree al fresco policies. All have reported the measure a success, with strong community approval and no harm to trade. All have found enforcement relatively straightforward, as strong community approval makes it largely self-enforcing.

“The only council cited by BATA was the one that retreated prematurely from this step: Hornsby. BATA quotes a Hornsby councillor who was so in tune with the community that he then lost his seat.

“BATA’s letter also misrepresents the position of Professor Chapman by implying that he opposes these measures. In fact, while he has reservations about smoking bans in some non-crowded outdoor areas, he’s on record as supporting smokefree policies in playgrounds, near building entrances and in al fresco dining areas.

“BATA promotes the education and butt-bin strategies of its BLT as an alternative. But the ‘reduction’ figure quoted is unsubstantiated, independent research finding such policies by themselves don’t work.

“This misleading letter shows the tobacco industry is bent on continuing its history of public deception to block popular and evidence-based health measures that might erode its tobacco sales.”
  

* www.wagga.nsw.gov.au/www/html/2900-policy-009---no-smoking-policy.asp

** Excerpts from BATA letter, ASH ‘re-buttal’ and other information:  www.ashaust.org.au/lv3/Lv3informationLG.htm

Comment:               Anne Jones, ASH          ph. (02) 9334-1876;  m. 0417-227-879

Comment/Media info: 
Stafford Sanders, Protecting Children and SmokeFree Aust workplace coalitions          ph. (02) 9334-1823;  m. 0412-070-194

 

 

Page last updated 27/11/08