ASH Australia media release
                                       July 2, 2008

Tobacco sellers' lobby against out-of-sight slammed as "contradictory, flawed, unsupported by evidence" - new study

 

Back to Media Releases index

Opposition from tobacco retailers to putting cigarettes out of sight in shops has been slammed in a new study as “contradictory, flawed and unsupported by evidence”.

Australian health and child welfare organisations have reacted by urging Australian governments to resist dodgy arguments and act on the evidence.

The study, published in the New Zealand Medical Journal*, examined arguments for and against display bans in New Zealand with reference to international experience, research studies, and interviews with smokers, ex-smokers and retailers.

The authors concluded: “Arguments for tobacco displays are contradictory, flawed, and unsupported by local and international research evidence, and by the overseas experience of tobacco-free display policies.”

The study found strong evidence an out-of-sight policy would protect children and support quitters. On the other hand it found no evidence for arguments for continued display of tobacco based on claimed “financial losses for retailers”, “economic disadvantages for small stores”, “normality/legality” of tobacco, “lack of evidence of effectiveness”, or staff safety/security.

Said Anne Jones, Chief Executive of Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) Australia:
“This confirms all the evidence we’ve put to governments that getting tobacco totally out of sight in all shops will improve the health of children by removing the promotion of addictive drugs.

“These same flawed arguments have been used by NSW retailers to the government, after being whipped up by a Philip Morris scare campaign.”

Putting tobacco totally out of sight in shops is supported by 40 health, child welfare, parenting, church and community organisations.**

“The Iemma Government must put protecting the health of children from addictive drugs ahead of unsupported and self-interested arguments of tobacco pushers”, says Anne Jones. 

* Full study at  www.ashaust.org.au/lv4/RetailNZstudy0806.pdf   
NZMJ abstract at  www.nzma.org.nz/journal/abstract.php?id=3120

** See list of supporting organisations at  www.ashaust.org.au/lv4/ProtectChildrenEndorsements.htm

Comment:                   
George Thomson, lead author, University of Otago    ph. +64-4-389-5319 ; +
64-4-478-9968 Anne Jones, CEO ASH Australia                            ph. (02) 9334-1876;  m. 0417-227-879

Media info:        Stafford Sanders, ASH Australia   ph. (02) 9334-1823;  m. 0412-070-194

 

 

 

Page last updated 2/7/08